Page images
PDF
EPUB

many, it would have been perfectly easy to say that they would cease to be mediators, and would become belligerents; but that was not a course which it was deemed advisable to adopt. They accepted the mediation at the request of Denmark, and with the consent of the other party; and so long as they saw any prospect of settling the question amicably by negotiation, he thought that was the best course to pursue.

sense of the absolute necessity and paramount importance of bringing about, without further delay, a satisfactory settlement of the armistice, and, as resulting from it, a settlement of the Schleswig question. With regard to the guarantee of England, what he had endeavoured to point out on a former occasion was, that the present position of matters could not bring that guarantee into operation. In the first place, England was at present acting in some degree in the capacity of a mediator; and Her Majesty's Government could not combine the functions of a mediator with those of a party in the cause, which they would do if they undertook to act in pursuance of their guarantee. In the next place, the question at issue was not whether Schleswig was to be wrested from the King-Duke to whom it belonged, it was a question complicated in its nature, but of a different kind-namely, what should be the internal administration of Schleswig-whether it should be, as the Danish Government wished it to be, a constitution combined with that of Denmark, or as the German party wished, a constitution combined with the Duchy of Holstein? It was not therefore a question of conquest, or of the forcibly wresting of a territory from a sovereign, but of the internal organisation and administration of the duchy. He trusted, however, that the good sense which he hoped animated all the parties concerned, would lead to a satisfactory settlement of the question without bringing into operation the guarantee, the existence of which he did not deny, but which, in his opinion, did not at present bear upon the practical question at issue.

MR. DISRAELI said, the noble Lord had informed them that, under his advice, the Crown of England had accepted the office of mediator. This being the case, he (Mr. Disraeli) wished to know how it was that, during that mediation more than 40,000 men, being different contingents of the German empire, had arrived at the seat of war-a circumstance which had led to the renewal of hostilities and to the revival of the blockade? He thought that, the moment such a hostile demonstration took place, the noble Lord was perfectly free to drop his position as a mediator, and to enforce the stringent character of the guarantee.

VISCOUNT PALMERSTON Undoubtedly, if Her Majesty's Government had thought fit to declare war against Ger

MR. COBDEN happened to be one of a deputation from Manchester who waited upon the noble Lord (Viscount Palmerston) some months ago upon this subject. They stated the vast importance to them of the trade with the Baltic and Hamburgh, and they urged the noble Lord to act the part of the mediator, and not to change this character for that of belligerent; and the noble Lord would best meet the wishes of the manufacturing community if he could with honour maintain his present pacific posture of mediator. Now, as to the vote before the House, this was, after all, a little loan; disguise it as they might, call it selling stock or issuing Exchequer-bills, still they were going to add to the permanent debt of the empire. But they would not act thus as individuals; individuals, if they had not the money to spend, would retrench, and diminish their expenditure. A reduction of 800,000l. had been made since framing the estimates; was it not possible to retrench a little more, rather than increase our debt? He measured the strength of this empire more by our finances than by our armaments or number of ships; and he must maintain that if we added 2,000,000l. more to our permanent debt, then, in spite of all our military and naval force, we should present ourselves in a crippled position before the world. Nor was he sure that the Chancellor had told the House the whole case for the next year in regard to expenditure; and that all these marchings and countermarchings in Ireland, all these encampments and increased fortifications, would not end in a very heavy bill being brought in next spring. It was very well to say that the Caffre war was a casual expense that would not occur again; but we had an Irish war and an Irish famine staring us in the face. But if we spent all we could get, and ran into debt besides, we should always be finding some casualty arising and telling against us. The Chancellor of the Exchequer stated that he was insolvent, and yet he could make loans to

of interest not exceeding 5 per cent,"thereby leaving to the country the opportunity of taking advantage of the future. state of the money market.

Trinidad, to Tobago, New Zealand, and to the gentry of Ireland to improve their We were just running the career which other nations had run, and which in the case of another nation we should condemn, but to which, in our own case, we seemed blind, and ready to treat England as if it had a charmed existence. That majority of the House, which in the spring refused a reduction in our armaments, and passed a vote authorising the expenditure, was bound to resolve to raise the money to raise it during this Session, and to raise it by an additional tax, whatever discontent it might create. Resolution agreed to. House resumed.

House adjourned at a quarter to Two o'clock.

HOUSE OF COMMONS,

Saturday, August 26, 1848.

MINUTES.] PUBLIC BILLS.-1° West India Colonies and Mauritius; Exchequer Bills; Consolidated Fund.

20 Post Horse Licenses, &c.; Postage on Newspapers (Channel Islands, &c..); Lock-up Houses; Drainage Certificates.

Reported.-Diplomatic Relations with the Court of Rome; Battersea Park, &c.

PETITIONS PRESENTED. By Mr. Maxwell, from the Parish of Killersherdiney, in the County of Cavan, for Encouragement to Schools in Connexion with the Church Education Society (Ireland).-From the High Sheriff and Grand Jury of the County of Mayo, for an Alteration of the Poor Law (Ireland).

WAYS AND MEANS.

Resolutions reported.

MR. HUME, referring to the resolutions, and to that part of the Government proposition which related to the raising the 2,000,000l. on Three per Cent stock, said that he objected to all borrowing, which, in itself, was a proof that the country had reached the ne plus ultra of taxation. Various additions had now been made to the debt of the country during past years, in time of peace; though that was the period when they ought to be considering how to lessen the charge. Had the House adopted his recommendations in favour of retrenchment, there would now be no necessity for the present loan. Moreover, he thought that one of the proposed modes of raising the required sum was ruinous, for borrowing on Three per Cent stock would be binding the country to pay 100l. for every 861. lent. He should therefore move to strike out of the last resolution all the words relating to that part of the proposition, and to insert in lieu of them the following words" on debentures at a rate

The CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER could by no means assent to the proposition; all who had preceded him in the office which he had now the honour to hold, had taken the course which he now proposed to take-all loans had been raised upon similar principles, and he saw no sufficient reason for departing from the existing practice.

MR. HUME merely wished to place his opinion on record, and he did not desire to do more than to divide upon the Bill. Report agreed to.

The House adjourned at Eight o'clock.

HOUSE OF LORDS,

Monday, August 28, '1848.

MINUTES.] PUBLIC BILLS. -1a Dublin Police; Poor Law Auditors Proceedings Restriction; Battersea Park, &c.

2a Sheep and Cattle Importation Prohibition; Sheep and Cattle Contagious Disorders Prevention; Labouring Poor (Ireland); Sugar Duties.

3 and passed:-Poor Removal (No. 2); Petty Bag, &c. Office (Court of Chancery); Commons Inclosure (No. 2); Poor Law Union Charges (No. 2).

SUGAR DUTIES BILL.

Order of the Day for Second Reading read.

EARL GREY rose to move that the Bill be now read the second time. One of the objects of the measure which he now intended to bring under the notice of their Lordships was to alter the Act of 1846; and the necessity for making such a change had been very greatly strengthened by the constantly-increasing distress of our sugargrowing colonics. It was not his present purpose, however, to occupy their Lordships' attention by any lengthened discourse; though, if he had been called upon to address them upon this subject at an carlier period of the year, he should, perhaps, have not thought it unfitting to enter into the question of the sugar duties much more in detail than he had now any intention of doing. Looking at the protracted duration of the Session -- remembering how few Members of either House still remained in town-considering, also, how much discussion had already taken place on the subject of those duties-he should abstain from saying more upon the present occasion than was absolutely necessary,

He felt that it was scarcely requisite for him to go over any very great portion of the ground that had already been travelled in making known the evidence upen which the provisions of the Bill were foundedit had been shown, as he conceived, beyond any doubt, that the policy hitherto pursued with regard to those duties could no longer be safely continued. It had been proved, as he believed in the clearest possible manner, that wages which had been raised to an excessive height by an artificial system of duties had proved deeply injurious both to the planter and the labourer. As far as he had been able to ascertain, the condition of the negro had not been in the least improved by the great increase of payment which he now received. In one of his despatches, dated the 3rd of May, the Governor of British Guiana said

“Estates worked by advances from England were a lottery, in which every one struggled to obtain a prize at the expense of his neighbour. Hence, labourers were seduced from one estate

to another; higher wages were the result, which, in the end, have absorbed the resources of the employers. The labourers are enriched; the owner has been left penniless. Had the diminution of wages taken place in 1847 rather than in 1848, many estates now jeopardised would, perhaps, have escaped; for the crops were large enough to have given profit, had expenses of labour not aborbed it. I consider it a great disadvantage to the progress of civilisation that the Creoles, young and old, have hitherto been enabled to earn, by two or three days' labour of six hours or seven hours each per week, more than

sufficient maintenance; they are thus induced to irregular habits; they shoot, fish, and lead a wandering life. Planters cannot regulate the work on their estates as farmers do in Europe: they are subject to the caprice of the negro-continuous labour cannot be had-the crops fail, while the liabilities increase-and there are not a few of the nominal possessors of property who are ground to the earth by the debts accumulated annually, from the enormous interest which the habits of West Indian dealings have introduced." From these despatches, as well as from the evidence adduced upon the subject of the sugar duties before the other House, it was clear that high wages had not been conducive to the welfare, but had greatly increased the demoralisation of the negroes, and that that evil state of things had been greatly aggravated by cultivation extended beyond its legitimate limits, and by competition carried on to a mischievous excess; and, what was worse, carried on upon borrowed capital, and at such inordinate charges as were wholly inconsistent with a sound mercantile system, or with legitimate mercantile profits. The effect of

to

the protecting duties had been to stimulate artificial production in a manner that was most injurious to fair and legitimate trade; and for the proof of that, he might refer to the papers which had been laid upon the table of the House. From those it appeared that in the Mauritius during the five years which elapsed from 1820 to 1824 inclusive, the produce had been 22,000,000 of French pounds; that in the subsequent five years it had risen to 42,000,000 lb.; that in 1830 it was 68,000,000 lb.; and in 1832, the year before the emancipation, it rose 73,000,000 lb.; and since the emancipation of the negroes, it had risen still more rapidly. In 1840-1, it had advanced to 76,000,000 lb.; and last year, 1847, it had reached the great amount of 133,000,000 lb., being an increase of sixfold in twenty-five years. Then there had been a great increase in the rate of wages, in spite of increased immigration; and, after all, the labour market was by no means well supplied-the employers were bidding against each other, and the necessary consequence of that condition of affairs was most injurious to the great body of the planters. It was impossible that this state of things could go on; and he found in the despatches of Sir W. Gomm, the Governor of the Mauritius, that he had foreseen the calamity. The report of the Committee of Council, dated February 19, 1845, stated, that " the crops of the five years from 1820 to 1824, averaged only 22,000,000 lb.; those of the subsequent five years, only 42,000,000 lb.; in 1830, the crop had risen to 68,000,009 lb.; and, in 1832, to 73,000,000 lb." In a despatch dated August 24, 1846, Sir W. Gomm wrote "I cannot be blind to the facts that, with the supply of labour in the colony, 80,000,000 lb. were with ease gathered in from the crop of 1844-5; that 100,000,000 lb. and upwards have been in like manner shipped of that just completed; and that many look with a full confidence to realising 120,000,000 lb. from that already in progress. Nor can I be without my apprehensions that, should a dark day arise, in succession to these consecutive seasons, the ever-increasing cultivation of the soil, supported, and indeed set on foot exclusively, by foreign aid, must bring extensive embarrassment. had read these extracts to prove that it had been foreseen at the time by Sir W. Gomm that the great increase which had taken place in the produce was not a healthy

"He

out reading any further statements, he thought he had shown that by this forced and artificial system-by the competition of the planters with each other-was the production unnaturally increased, and the wages of the labourer were raised. But let it not be supposed that he blamed these parties; he did not think them blameable; he thought them imprudent, but their imprudence was as nothing compared with the imprudence of Parliament. The two Houses of Parliament were responsible for having fostered and encouraged this unnatural system, which could have led to no other result. Looking to the future, however, in his opinion, notwithstanding their actual and immediate distress, there was a fair prospect of reasonable profits in our sugar-growing colonies under a better sys

increase; that it had been stimulated by | rience of the planters in the Mauritius the artificial system which had been pur- that free labour in that colony was decisued; and this cause had not only affected dedly cheaper than slave labour in Cuba. the Mauritius, but had affected our colonies There was only one of the colonies in in the west, which had been carrying on which this was not the case, and it was cultivation with borrowed capital, upon singular that it was the very colony where which the charges were of the heaviest the wages were highest. In Guiana the kind; for, the trade being a hazardous labourers strenuously resisted the reducone, the charge must be enormous. The tion of wages, and no wonder; they had artificial cultivation of sugar was increased been spoiled by the extraordinary high by another circumstance; the merchants at wages they had received owing to the home, who advanced money for the exten- forced and artificial system adopted by the sion of the cultivation in the colonies, were planters. In Barbadoes, Antigua, and themselves trading far beyond their own other colonies, with less natural advancapital, and trusted more to credit than to tages, where wages had not been so extracapital. In this manner was the produc- vagantly forced up, they had been much tion of sugar artificially increased. With-reduced, and a more natural and wholesome relation had been established between master and labourer. The report of the stipendiary magistrate of Antigua for the half-year ending December 31, 1847, stated, "The number of young persons employed in field labour has increased during this half-year, and I confidently repeat my conviction that in a few years a numerous native peasantry will arise to cultivate the soil and supersede the necessity of emigration. The reduction of wages has had the effect of bringing more labour into the market.” He stated that there was an increased amount of deposits in the savings banks, which was one evidence of increased industry amongst the labourers. Another effect which he had predicted was the diminution of the cost of production, and improvements in the cultivation and He admitted the extreme severity of manufacture of sugar, which would be the existing distress, and he deplored as caused by competition; and on this point moch as any man the calamities which had also he was able to prove that he had not visited so large and respectable a class. been deceived. Sir Henry Light, GoverThen with respect to the future, he had nor of Guiana, in a letter dated the 25th ventured to predict that, if protection were of June, 1848, enclosed a document from withdrawn, and the system of cultivation Dr. Shier, stating that the subsoil drainwas placed upon a proper footing, wages ing of canefields in Demerara in compariwould inevitably fall; and that prediction son with a neighbouring field under comhad been verified. With regard to the mon cultivation, had given an increase of comparative cost of free and slave labour, produce of 100 per cent in the former as he had met the other day with a state- compared with the latter, though under ment in a Mauritius newspaper, the Mau- very great disadvantages. "I believe,' ritius Mail, in which the writer said- he said, "that the planters are beginning "We asked one of our most experienced to open their eyes on the true protection, planters, to whose opinion every one who namely, better cultivation; but very few knows him will bend, which he preferred; have the means of standing the outlay and he laughed at us for the question. I necessary for this new mode of cultivahad a choice band of slaves that were at- tion." As to manufacture, Sir H. Light tached to me,' he said, for I occupied my- said, in his despatch of February 14, 1848, self about their welfare; all they did is describing the success of Dr. Shier's imnow easily surpassed by a band of the provements, "Nothing can equal the same number of Madras Indians.'" He slovenly, unscientific way in which sugar was completely confirmed by the expe- is made on those estates on which the

tem.

Lord Harris said "Up to July, 1847,
very great facility generally existed in
procuring both money and bills, but neither
a cheap nor good sugar was the result; on
the contrary, it is notorious that now, for
the first time, will the character of Tri-
nidad sugar change in the estimation of
English buyers, as a very great improve-
ment has taken place. This was the
20th of June, 1848. In Antigua, Go-
vernor Higginson wrote (June, 1848), that
there were glimmerings of returning con-
fidence; that wages had fallen from 1s. 10d.
to 6d. a day; and he said,
"The prevail-

[ocr errors]

common process is used." Lord Harris, in a private letter, dated the 21st of July, 1848, after describing the importance of improved cultivation, stated, with regard to the manufacturing process, "A report was received by the last packet of prices set on some samples of sugar made on the day, at the same estate, and from canes taken from the same field-value of sugar made by Dr. Mitchell's process, 47s. per cwt.; by old process, 36s. per cwt.: there being no increased expense, and nearly double the quantity of saccharine matter extruded." These statements sufficed to show that there was in our colonies a greating opinion here undoubtedly is, that unless capability of improvement. He now pro- free-labour produce be protected, the maceeded to show that even under the pres-jority of estates must be abandoned; but I sure of existing difficulties the sugar cul- incline to believe that the worst has passed.' tivation was in a process of improvement. He trusted that he had proved that the old In British Guiana he found that, in the first protective system was essentially an unsix months of 1848, the quantity of sugar sound one; and although the return to a exported was 21,528 hhds.; and, in 1847, better and a healthier state of things might for the corresponding period it was only be attended, and unfortunately was attend19,120 hhds.; showing an increase of ed, with no small pressure and distress2,408 hhds.; that the export of rum for still he believed that that change bore in it the first half of the year 1848 was 11,653 the seeds of prosperity, and well-grounded puncheons, while for the similar period of hope for the future. But if this was his 1847 it amounted only to 7,266; showing opinion, he might be asked on what grounds an increase of 4,387. On the other hand, he justified the Bill, the second reading of the exports of molasses in 1848 were which he had now to move? The object of 4,167 casks; and in 1847, 6,552 casks; that Bill was to extend to a longer period, a diminution of 2,385 casks, or more than and grant to a greater extent, the protecone-third. Now, when it was considered tion and privileges accorded by the Bill of that the quantity of molasses depended 1846 to the British sugar-growing colonies; upon the imperfection in the process of and the grounds on which he thought such the manufacture of sugar, the diminution a measure justifiable were these :-In the of the export of the refuse article showed first place there existed amongst the sugar an improvement in the mode of manufac- growers a panic, which, if not checked, turing the sugar. There was, therefore, must lead to the most disastrous results. an increase during the first six months of His own opinion was, that this panic was a the year 1848 over the first six months of groundless one; but the planters had been 1847 in the export of rum and sugar, the so long taught to rely on protection, that manufactured article, and a decrease in he could not be surprised at their considerthat of molasses, the refuse article. In ing the withdrawal of that protection as Trinidad, Lord Harris, in his despatch, equivalent to ruin. Under the influence, dated the 19th of June, 1848, said, "Mat- then, of this panic, it was probable that the ters are now as nearly as possible at their planters would have adopted a course which worst; artificial assistance will do little or must inevitably have led to great injury, nothing. Those who have energy may not only to themselves, but to the empire. still continue to cultivate the soil; by im- They would, if something were not done, provements, by advances in scientific cul- in all probability have abandoned their estivation, or by economy, I believe they tates, and discontinued a species of cultimay still succeed. The number of acres vation which could not be resumed except in cultivation will be less, the crop will at an immense sacrifice of capital. But, diminish in quantity, but it will not be the besides, it was now confessed on all hands, less lucrative; I believe more so, and a that the amount of advantage intended by natural state of things to producers, which the Act of 1846 to be conferred on the will place matters upon a more wholesome colonists, had not, as yet, been fully or footing. But there were already hopes practically realised. These circumstances in this island that improvement had begun. justified the grant of some relief to the

[ocr errors]
« EelmineJätka »