Page images
PDF
EPUB

Some Judges have acted up to the extreme limit of Jolly v. Rees in relieving a husband from liability for goods supplied contrary to his orders. The liability being gone there is an end of all difficulty, but if the liability cannot be got rid of it is in the next place important that the debtor who has to bear a burden innocently contracted, so far as he is concerned, should not be sent to prison for non-payment, as the element of fraudulent intent or conduct is altogether wanting.

The whole subject has now at any rate been thoroughly thought out. It is very improbable that we shall obtain any better evidence than that which was extracted by the select committee. We know the opinion of County Court Judges, and we think it is the fact that a considerable majority are of opinion that the restricted power of imprisonment which now exists is most salutary, and should be preserved. We know that many Judges regret that abolition of imprisonment for debt has gone the length it has, and would gladly see it restored, whilst the commercial community must feel that it has considerably altered their relations with the public. This doubtless raises the question whether legislation should impose difficulties on trade by rendering debts impossible of recovery. We are decidedly of opinion that it should not, and we think that Sir HENRY JAMES's grave social and economical questions should not be taken into consideration in deliberating upon the operation of our legal machinery. There is ample evidence that impending imprisonment forces the settlement of claims which otherwise would be absolutely ignored in a very large number of cases. The few cases of hardship of which we hear are hardly a satisfactory set-off against such a result, and we conceive that debtor and creditor should be left to the difficulties and perils which each at present incurs; and even on a balance of disadvantages, we believe it would be more detrimental to a working man to be deprived of credit than to suffer occasional imprisonment.

LAND TITLES AND TRANSFER BILL. WHEN a Lord Chancellor adopts a Bill previously introduced by his predecessor, who was opposed to himself in politics, it appears clear that the principle of the Bill must be taken as acknowledged to be correct by both political parties, and the main discussion upon the Bill can be upon questions of detail only. Lord Cairns has presented to the House of Lords what is, in effect, the Bill of Lord Selborne with Vice-Chancellor Sir Charles Hall's alterations.

As both the learned lords are agreed that "it is expedient to make further provisions for the simplification of the title to land, and for facilitating the transfer of land in England," it behoves all real property lawyers carefully to study the Bill and render their best assistance in making it as workable as possible.

We have not at present had time to consider the 171 sections of which the Bill consists sufficiently to make any suggestions, but we propose at an early date, when we have given the Bill more attention, to state our views upon its different parts. At present we must content ourselves with giving, in general terms, the objects proposed to be effected.

The Bill proposes to allow any person entitled, legally or equitably, to an estate in fee, whether in possession or reversion or charged or not, and whether it be an estate in tail or in fee simple, or a base fee, or any person authorised with or without the consent of another person, to dispose, by way of absolute sale, of an estate in fee simple, in possession or reversion or charged or not, ora purchaser of a similar estate in fee simple, to register himself as the proprietor of the land, but in some cases certain consents are required. Registration may be of three kinds—(a) of a title absolute that is good without any other exception or reservation than those mentioned in the register or in the Bill; (b) of a title limited as good from a certain date mentioned in the register, with the above exception and reservation; and (c) of the applicant, as proprietor only, without any title. In every case the registrar is to be furnished with a correct description of the land, accompanied (except in the case of incorporeal hereditaments) by a plan, and with statements of all interested persons, of their estates and powers, and of all charges and incumbrances. In cases of applications for registration, as proprietor only, the applicant is to satisfy the registrar that he, or some one entitled to a prior estate, or his mortgagee or beneficiary, is in possession or receipt of the rents; and in cases of compulsory registration, to which we shall presently refer, the registrar is to be satisfied with the deed of conveyance. In cases of application for registration with a title absolute or limited, an abstract of title, with such evidence as general orders may require, is to be furnished, and the registrar must be satisfied that the applicant, or his predecessors in title, or some person entitled to some estate under the same common title, has or have been in possession or in receipt of the rents for not less than five years immediately prior to the date of the application. The registrar and an examiner of title are to examine the title, and the former may require further particulars and evidence of the identity and correctness of the lands and their quantities, but the registrar is not to require a title to commence earlier than at least (sic) forty years previously to the time of registration, unless he is of opinion that there is reason to suppose that some settlement or will

prior to that period may have been executed which might prejudicially affect the title; and the registrar may accept as sufficient evidence recitals, statements, and descriptions of facts, matters, and parties, in deeds, instruments, and statutory declarations twenty years old. When the application is for registration otherwise than as proprietor only, a notice of it, containing a description of the land, the name and description of the applicant, and a statement of the effect of the proposed registration, as excluding adverse claims, and a time and place for showing cause against it, is to be advertised in conformity with general orders, and a copy of the notice is to be posted on or near the land, and served upon such persons as the registrar shall direct. Before registration with title absolute or limited, the applicant and his solicitor, or agent, or certified conveyancer, and such other person or persons, if any, as the registrar shall require, are to make affidavit that all deeds, wills, and writings relating to the title of the land, or any part thereof, and all facts material to the title thereto, and all charges, liens, incumbrances, contracts, and dealings affecting the same, or any part thereof, or giving any right as against the applicant, have to the full extent of their respective knowledge, information, and belief been made known to the registrar; but the registrar is to be empowered to dispense with such affidavit, either from the applicant or from any other person, when he shall think it reasonable so to do, or to permit the terms of it to be so modified as circumstances might require. When, after the 1st Jan. 1879, a sale of land in fee simple, in possession, or reversion, and charged, or otherwise, takes place, there not being then a registered proprietor, and the purchaser might apply for registration, some person must be registered as proprietor, with absolute or limited title, or as proprietor only, and the instrument of conveyance is until such registration to operate in equity only, and is not to be effectual at law to pass the legal estate. A registered proprietor, whether owner or trustee only, is to be deemed to be owner in fee simple, with full powers of disposition, subject only to the charges and estates referred to in the bill or stated on the register; but such proprietor is to be able to deal with the land by the same modes as he now can, but except in the interval between the death of a proprietor and the entry on the register of another proprietor, there is always to be a registered proprietor in whom the legal estate, subject as aforesaid, is to be deemed vested. Leasehold estates, where more than twenty-one years are unexpired, or where two lives are still living, and estates in dower and by the courtesy may also be registered under similar conditions to those relating to estates in fee.

Upon registration an entry is to be made in a book, to be called "The Land Register," of the name of the proprietor, a description of the land, with a reference when necessary or convenient to a map, whether the title is absolute or limited, and, if so, the limit, and, if either, the particulare of all prior estates, leases, and incumbrances other than those referred to in the bill, but no trust of any kind is to be referred to, nor is it to be shown that the proprietor is mortgagee, or has a security only. The registrar is to give the proprietor "a land certificate," the form of which has yet to be prescribed, which is to contain a transcript of so much of the register as relates to the land or lease, and upon the registrar being satisfied of the loss or destruction of the certificate he may grant a new one. The deposit of the certificate with a memorandum endorsed at the time stating the date and purpose of the deposit, and bearing a proper mortgage stamp, is to create a lien on the land equivalent to that made under the powers of the Bill, so as to take precedence of all statutory charges not previously noted on the certificate. The proprietor may charge the land, and the instrument of charge may or may not confer a power of sale, and the owner of the charge may be registered. The registered charge will imply (unless the contrary be stated in the instrument of charge) a covenant by the registered proprietor for the time being of the land to pay the money and interest. If the instrument of charge confer a power of sale, the registered proprietor of the charge may exercise it, and transfer the land as if he were the registered proprietor thereof; if no power of sale be conferred he can only enter into possession or apply to the court for sale. As between themselves registered charges are to rank according to the order of their registration, and not of their creation, and upon the satisfaction of a charge, the registrar on proof, or on the requisition of the proprietor of the charge, is to enter a note thereof on the register upon which the land is to be deemed discharged.

The Bill makes provision for the entry of the new owner on the transfer of any land, but until that has been done the person on the register is to be deemed proprietor, and it also provides for alteration of the register in the case of marriage of a female proprietor or of the death or bankruptcy of a proprietor and of sales by the court or sheriff.

The Bill also creates a system of notices and caveats both as against registration and against the transfer by a registered proprietor, and also provides for an inspection of the register by a limited class of persons.

The Land Registry office is to be in London, and the business is to be conducted by the Registrar with the aid of such assistant registrars, whose acts are to be deemed the acts of the registrar,

examiners of title, clerks, messengers, and servants, as the Lord Chancellor may fix, with the consent of the Treasury, and the fees to be taken for registration are to be settled by the registrar with the sanction of the Lord Chancellor, and the Lord Chancellor may from time to time fix a scale of fees to be paid to the examiners of title, and also of costs to be paid to solicitors or certificated conveyancers in respect of any service to be rendered by them in any matter relating to proceedings under the Act, and any scale of costs so fixed may, if the Lord Chancellor thinks fit, be based on an ad valorem principle.

The Bill contains forms of transfer and charge which are to be as effectual as any other form would have been. When it appears probable that the amount of business to be transacted in a particular district will be sufficient to pay the expenses of a registry there, the Lord Chancellor, with the consent of the Treasury, is to have power to form a district registry, with a proper staff.

The staff of the present registry office, with all papers, are to be transferred to the new office.

The above is a general sketch of the greater part, although, of course, not all, of the proposed objects of the Bill, and upon a future occasion we propose to carefully consider the Bill in detail.

FALSE REPRESENTATION BY AGENTS.

THERE has been a somewhat singular concurrence of cases lately on the extremely important question under what circumstances an agent binds his principal by a false representation. The case of Swift v. Winterbotham must be familiar to all our readers, and is an excellent illustration of the difficulties which surround the subject. There the manager of a branch bank had been applied to concerning the solvency of a gentleman well known in the locality of the bank, and had expressed a favourable opinion. This opinion was conveyed by letter, the applicant being the manager of another banking company. The form of the application was this: "I shall be much obliged by the favour of your opinion in confidence of the respectability and standing of Sir William Russell, Bart., M.P. for Norwich, and whether you consider him responsible to the extent of £50,000." And the answer addressed to the bank was: "I am in receipt of your favour of the 8th inst., and beg to say in reply that Sir Wm. Russell, Bart., M.P. for Norwich, is the lord of the manor of Charlton Kings, near this town, with a rent roll, I am told, of over £7000 per annum, the receipt of which is in his own hands, and has large expectancies; and I do not believe he would incur the liability you name unless he was certain to meet the engagement." Goddard, one of the defendants, signed this as "manager," the representation was acted upon,. and a heavy loss sustained, which it was sought to recover against the bank of which Goddard was manager, and himself personally.

All that we are are now concerned with is the law involved, and we may therefore say shortly that a verdict being obtained by the plaintiffs, it was attempted to set it aside, but the rules for this purpose were discharged by the Queen's Bench. That court considered that the bank was bound by the signature of its manager (within sect. 6 of 9 Geo. 4, c. 14), and thus liable for the false representation. The Court of Exchequer Chamber reversed this decision (30 L. T. Rep. N. S. 31). The ruling of the court of appeal seems to us to be sound law, and moreover it is supported by a recent decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, which we reported last week, namely, Mackay v. The Commercial Bank of New Brunswick (30 L. T. Rep. N. S. 180).

The better plan in considering the effect of judicial decisions as making the law, is to take those emanating from the highest courts of appeal, and if they are not in conflict with other cases of similar authority to disregard decisions in the courts of first instance which are opposed to them. In Mackay's case, Swift v. Winterbotham (sub nom. Swift v. Jewesbury, ubi sup.) was noticed, and the whole subject fully discussed. We will make it our business now to consider what may now be taken as established beyond controversy.

In the first place, is the signature of the manager of a banking company a signature by the company as the party to be charged within the Act of Lord Tenterden? The decision of the Exchequer Chamber in Swift v. Jewesbury, is emphatically in the negative. Lord Coleridge, in delivering judgment, said, "Whether we look at the antecedent reason, or at the Parliamentary exposition contained in the statute, it seems to me that the true construction is, that in order to charge a person under Lord Tenterden's Act with a fraudulent misrepresentation as to the capacity of another, you must produce a written document containing the misrepresentation, and signed by the person sought to be charged." Turning to Mackay's case we find a common law representation-that is to say, a representation by an agent acting within the scope of his authority. There the facts were that the defendants' cashier, who discharged the duties of manager, sent a telegram to persons who were hesitating about accepting certain drafts, such telegram purporting to come from the drawer, that remittances required to meet previous drafts had been sent Upon this representation the plaintiffs accepted the subseque; t drafts. The representation was that the remittance had been sent but when the manager sent the telegram in the name of

the drawer the latter was insolvent and had absconded. The defendant bank had indorsed the subsequent drafts and it was consequently to their interest that they should be accepted. The main question was this-was the position of the manager such as to bring the representation which he made within the scope of his authority? The Committee recognised the difficulty of defining precisely the position of an agent which will confer the power to bind the principal by his fraud. Obviously circumstances may vary and it is almost an impossibility to state a principle which shall govern all cases. The nearest approach to such a principle which we can conceive is this: If an agent acting within the scope of his employment makes a representation in the ordinary course of business for the benefit, of his principal and such representation is false, the principal is liable. That is to say, that no express authority to make the particular representation is necessary, and, moreover, it is not essential that the principal should actually benefit by the fraud. The distinction between cases of an agent making a representation which does not in any way affect the principal's interest and cases in which it does is well shown by Smith v. Jewesbury (sup.) and Barwick v. The English Joint Stock Bank (16 L. T. Rep. N. S. 461). In deciding that the representation of Goddard in the firstnamed case, was a representation by him only in his individual capacity, Lord Coleridge said: This does not at all conflict with the case of Barwick v. The English Joint Stock Bank, and cases of that description, because there can be no doubt that where an agent of a corporation, or a joint stock company, in conducting its business, does something of which the joint stock company take advantage, and by which they profit, or by which they may profit, and it turns out that the act which is so done by their agent is a fraudulent act, justice points out, and authority supports justice in maintaining, that they cannot afterwards repudiate the agency, and say that the act which has been done by the agent is not an act for which they are liable."

66

In further illustration of this subject reference may be made to Addie v. The Western Bank of Scotland (L. Rep. 1 H. of L. Cas. Sc. 145), in which was laid down by Lord Cranworth that if by the frauds of the agents of an incorporated company third persons have been defrauded, the corporation may be made responsible to the extent to which its funds have profited by the frauds; and to Ranger v. The Great Western Railway Company (5 H. of L. Cas. 86), where the same noble Lord said, "strictly speaking, a corporation cannot of itself be guilty of a fraud. But where a corporation is formed for the purpose of carrying on a trading or other speculation for profit, such as forming a railway, these objects can only be accomplished by the agency of individuals; and there can be no doubt that if the agents employed conduct themselves fraudu lently, so that if they had been acting for private employers, the persons for whom they were acting would have been affected by their frand, the same principles must prevail where the principal under whom the agent acts is a corporation." Therefore the same general principle applies whenever the nature of the business transacted by the agent gives him opportunities of fraudulent representation for the benefit of his employers-whether those employers be a corporation or individuals.

We said at the outset that where courts of appeal have given decisions which are uniform and consistent, the safest course is to disregard inconsistent decisions of courts of first instance. We must, however, take the liberty of observing that we found a difficulty in seeing how, in Swift v. Winterbotham, quite apart from the 6th section of Lord Tenterden's Act, the reply of Goddard to the application made by him in his individual capacity could bind the bank. We thoroughly agree with the counsel who argued for the bank, that it would be almost impossible for a bank to carry on business if banks were to be made responsible for every untrue representation of solvency of individuals made by branch managers, for no purpose connected with the business of the bank. Possible profit accruing to the bank was not an element in that case, as it was in all the other cases, and conspicuously in Mackay's 8 case. Where there is the element of possible profit, that being the object of the representation, and the representation is made in the course of business, as Lord Coleridge says, it is but justice, and justice is supported by authority, that the principal should be liable.

LAW LIBRARY.

Rawlinson on Instructions for Wills. By JAMES RAWLINSON, Solicitor. London: Stevens and Sons. THE object of the author of this little work is to furnish solicitors with a guide to taking instructions for wills, and we think it may fairly be said to come up to the standard aimed at by Mr. Rawlinson, and that it will be found of service to those whose practical professional experience is limited. We cannot, however, adopt the opinion expressed in the preface, that it is incumbent on a solicitor to explain to a client (giving instructions for the preparation of his will) the extent to which his will will be affected by the several statutes relating to such document. The work before us is certainly a useful one, consisting as it does for the most part of references to such enactments as particularly relate to the subject of wills. It will also be found of use to articled clerks.

LEGISLATION AND JURIS-
PRUDENCE.

HOUSE OF LORDS.
Tuesday, April 14.
ATTORNEYS' AND SOLICITORS' BILL.
This Bill was read a third time and passed.

HOUSE OF COMMONS.
Monday, April 13.

OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON BILL.

MR. CHARLEY moved the second reading of this bill. The object of the Bill was to throw a protection round young girls. It was founded upon the report of a select committee, and it had received the assent of the House of Commons on two OccasionsSIR H. SELWIN IBBETSON said there was no opposition to the second reading of the Bill. The Home Secretary reserved to himself the right of proposing alterations if he should think fit in committee. The Bill was then read a second time.

INFANTICIDE BILL

Mr. CHARLEY, in moving the second reading of this Bill, said its object was to check infanticide. The severity of punishment too frequently defeated the object of the present law, and the Bill aimed at carrying the law into effect by proposing to mitigate the severity of the punishment. -Mr. HOLKER supported the measure, because he believed it to be a good and useful one.— -The HOME SECRETARY did not oppose the second reading, as the principle of the Bill had already been accepted by the commissioners on capital punishment. But the details of the measure would require considerable modification, and he now consented to the second reading of the Bill on the understanding that it should be referred to a select committee along with the Bill introduced by the Recorder of the City of London, in order that the whole subject might be carefully discussed. The Bill was then read a second time.

Tuesday, April 14.

IMPRISONMENT FOR DEBT BILL.

MR. BASS, in moving the second reading of his Bill to abolish imprisonment for debt by county courts for sums under £5., intimated that if the measure reached committee he should be willing to eonfine it to debts of £2.--The Bill was opposed by Mr. LOPES, who argued that the power of commitment vested in the county court judges was not a hardship, because in every case the judge must be satisfied that the debtor had the means of paying, but contumaciously refused to do so. Sir H. JAMES described the county court system as a great debt-collecting machine kept up in the interest of small traders.-Mr. ROEBUCK contended that the alteration of the law contemplated by the Bill would inflict serious injury on the working classes themselves by depriving them of the power of obtaining credit.After some discussion, in which Mr. HOLKER, Serjt. SIMON, Mr. S. LLOYD, and Mr. FORSYTH took part, Mr. Secretary CROSS said that if any evils existed they sprang from the manner which the law was administered rather than from the law itself, and he recommended that the County Court Judges should lay their heads together and frame some rule by which they might arrive at an accurate test of a man's ability to pay the debt he had been adjudged to pay by the court. The real object of the Act of Parliament was that where proof was given to the satisfaction of the judge that the debtor who had the money to pay, and wilfully refused, or neglected to do so in such a way as to practically amount to fraud, deserved imprisonment. The proper remedy would, therefore, be that suggested by the Select Committee - namely, in the extension of the Fraudulent Debtors' Act of 1869.--The debate closed with a short speech by Colonel BERESFORD in favour of the Bill as an instalment of justice, after which the House divided and negatived the second reading by 215 to 72. The Bill was therefore lost.

Wednesday, April 15.

in

REGISTRATION OF VOTERS (Ireland). Mr. MELDON gave notice that he would on Friday move for leave to introduce a Bill to amend the law relative to the registration of voters in Ireland.

AMENDMENT BILL.

MARRIED WOMEN'S PROPERTY ACT (1870) Mr. MORLEY moved the second reading of this Bill. He explained that as the law at present stood a very large number of unmarried women and widows held farms and were engaged in trade. While unmarried they might incur debt, and should they marry, their creditors had no power to recover the debt, either from themselves or the husbands whom they might marry. He knew of a case where an unmarried woman obtained a piano, which was to be paid for in eight quarterly instalments. After she had paid four she married, took the piano with her, and the creditor lost the remainder of the money which was his due. Great hardship was inflicted by this state of the law,

and what his Bill aimed at was to provide a remedy. Unfortunately, the measure had been made retrospective in its operation; but this point could be amended incommittee. -Mr.A. MARTEN moved that the Bill be read on that day six months. The hon. member contended that this Bill would induce a principle which was novel in reference to the relations between husband and wife; it would treat the wife as though she died when her marriage took place and the husband became her executor. He would be liable in certain cases to account for the wife's property which he received, and that at any future time, so that a woman who might be entitled to give £1000 to her godchild could not give a £10 note to her husband without his becoming liable to account for it. The onus also was thrown upon the husband of showing that he had not received property which was liable to the wife's debts, whereas the liability of prov. ing any such receipt should surely rest upon the creditor. There was really no practical hardship in the existing law which called for any such alterations as were proposed in the present measure. In addition to the objections on principle to the substance of this Bill, there were also many objections upon matters of comparative detail, and what he would suggest was that, instead of adopting this Bill, the House should rather proceed by extending the provisions of the Act of 1870. The present Bill was also of a piecemeal description, whereas, if anything was required to be done, it should be by a complete legislative measure, which laid down clearly the principle upon which the courts should proceed.--Sir F. GOLDSMID agreed that the Act of 1870 should be dealt with by a comprehensive measure; and such a Bill was brought forward last session, and would have passed but for the new half-past twelve rule. This measure had not been brought forward this year; and therefore the only question now before them was, whether they should not by the present measure attempt to remedy certain proved instances of injustice.--Mr. S. HILL thought that husband and wife should never be treated in reference to property as entirely separate persons; but still there were certain things in the Act of 1870 which clearly required remedy. In the present Bill there were many points which needed amendment but still upon the whole he should support the second reading, it being a measure which would remedy many existing evils.-The ATTORNEY GENERAL could have wished that this had been a Bill more apt and proper to give effect to the object sought to be attained; but still it hit what was clearly a blot in the existing law. Before the Act of 1870 a man who married a woman who was possessed of property, and who also owed debts, acquired her property, and also became liable to pay her debts. The Act of 1870 made two alterations in that law, one protecting certain property of which a woman became possessed, and giving it to her as her separate property; and the other alteration was made by providing that the husband should not be liable for the wife's debts after he had married her. The consequence of this was, that the husband in many cases acquired all his wife's property, while her creditors got nothing, he not being liable for her debts. The object of the promoters of this Bill was to make the husband liable for the debts of his wife to the extent of the property that by reason of his marriage he had derived from his wife. No doubt some parts of the Bill would require amendment, one objection to the Bill being that it did not go far enough, but these things could be amended in committee, and therefore he should support the second reading of the Bill.- The ATTORNEY-GENERAL for IRELAND, in assenting to the second reading, did so only upon the assumption that certain defects in it would be amended in committee. Mr. MELDON opposed the Bill, principally upon the ground of ite being piecemeal Legislation. At present there were no means of making married women liable, but still there would in many cases be difficulty in enacting that property should be followed so as to make it meet the wife's debts under certain circumstances. It was also necessary that several other alterations should be made in the law as it now stood, but the matter had, in his opinion, better stand over until some more perfect measure could be brought in.--Mr. GREGORY agreed that in some instances there would be great dificulty in following settled preperty, but still, upon the whole, he should support the Bill, though no doubt it would, in some particulars, require alteration. Mr. MORLEY, in reply, admitted that there were certain defects in the Bill which he should be glad to remedy; his only object being to enact the principle contained in it.

The Bill was then read a second time.

RETURNING OFFICERS' CHARGES.

Sir H. JAMES obtained leave to bring in a Bill to control the charges of returning officers at parliamentary elections.

The Bill was brought in and read a first time.

LAND TITLES AND TRANSFER BILL. (Continued from p. 417.)

Effect on Registration.

35. Estate tail, &c. of proprietor barred by registration. The registration of any person as proprietor of land shall bar any estate tail, or enlarge any base fee, to which respectively such person was immediately before the registration entitled therein, and all remainders and reversions expectant thereon.

36. The registered proprietor to have the fee simple, subject, &c., but prior estates, &c., may be barred by Statute of Limitations.-The person registered as proprietor of land shall have an estate in fee simple therein, together with all rights, privileges, and appurtenances therewith enjoyed or thereunto belonging or appurtenant thereto, free from all rights, interests, claims, and demands whatsoever, including any right, interest, claim or demand of Her Majesty, her heirs and successors, except and subject as follows; that is to say,

(1) If the registration be as proprietor only,
except and subject to any adverse estate,
interest, or title subsisting in or to the
land at the date of the registration :
(2) If the registration be as proprietor with
limited title, except and subject to any
adverse estate, interest, or title, sub-
sisting in or to the land at the date
mentioned upon the register, and the
rights of all persons interested under or
by virtue of any such estate, interest, or

title:

(3) Whether the registration be as proprietor with absolute or limited title, except and subject to the prior estates, and incumbrances, if any, entered on the register, and to any power of re-entry, shifting clause, restriction, or condition, notice whereof shall be entered on the register, and to all such charges and interests as are by this Act declared not to be incumbrances:

Provided, that all such prior estates, titles, rights, incumbrances, charges, and interests, may at any time be barred or extinguished, by any statute of limitations, or otherwise, in the same manner as if this Act had not passed.

37. What are not to be deemed incumbranaes.— The following charges and interests shall not be deemed incumbrances within the meaning of this Act; that is to say,

(1) Tithes, payments in lien of tithes, tithe rentcharges, and charges by reason of the merger or extinguishment of tithes, or of tithe rent charges:

(2) Land tax, and charges under the Land Tax Acts, in respect of purchased or redeemed land tax. Succession duty, subject and without prejudice to the provision as to the same hereinafter contained :

(3) Liability to repair the chancel of any church, by reason that the hereditaments were part of any rectory:

(4) Liability, by reason of tenure, to the repair of highways, fee-farm rents, quit and chief rents, heriots and reliefs, and other charges having their origin in tenure :

(5) Rights of common, rights of way, watercourses, and rights of water and other easements:

(6) Rights of fishing and sporting, seignorial and manorial rights of all descriptions, and franchises, exerciseable over the registered lands:

(7) Embankments and drainage rights, and taxes or charges imposed or created, or to be created under any public Act of Parlia ment authorising the charging of lands with the expense of and incident to their improvement:

(8) Rights of or incidental to the passage of

gas or water, or any charge imposed by public Act of Parliament on account thereof respectively, or rights or powers incident thereto :

(9) Tenancies created before or after registra

tion for any term not exceeding twentyone years, or of which at the time of the original registration there shall not be unexpired more than twenty-one years, or for any less estate, in cases where there is an occupation in pursuance of any such tenancies.

And all land of which there shall be a registered proprietor shall be deemed to be subject to such of the above charges and interests as may be for the time being subsisting so as to affect the same; nevertheless, where the existence of any such charges or interests as are mentioned in this section is proved to the registrar, to his satisfaction, the registrar may, if he shall think fit, enter on the register notice of such charges or interests, in such manner as he may think fit.

38. The first registered proprietor to have power to dispose of the land, and he or his nominee may

give receipts to purchasers.-The person registered as proprietor shall have power absolutely to dispose of the land of which he shall for the time being be registered proprietor, and if their shall be any money or other consideration paid or given, 'his receipt or the receipt of any other person to whom such money or other consideration shall with his privity be paid or given, shall be an effectual discharge for the same, and such power of disposal shall be subject only as the pro prietor's estate in fee simple may be subject as hereinbefore mentioned, and to such (if any) lease or charges as shall have been granted or made and shall have been registered under this Act, and to any charge created by deposit of the land certificate as hereinafter mentioned, and as regards corporeal hereditaments to such (if any) easements and incorporeal rights as shall have been created, and notice whereof shall have been entered on the register as hereinafter mentioned, and to such (if any) of the other legal estates hereinafter mentioned as may for the time being be subsisting; and, subject only as aforesaid, no transferee for valuable consideration shall be bound or affected by any express or constructive notice of any trust, equity of redemption, or equitable estate, right, title, or interest or lis pendens.

39. Trusts, &c. to be binding as between registered proprietor and cestui que trust, &c.-Every regis. tered proprietor who is a trustee for any other person under any will, deed, or instrument executed either before or at the time of or after the first registration of such land, or who as between himself and any other person is only a mortgagee or has only a security, shall, as between himself and all persons beneficially entitled or interested under such trust, or subject to the mortgage or security entitled or interested to, or in the land comprised in the mortgage or security, be and continue subject to such and the same obligations, liabilities, and equities in every respect as if he had not been registered as proprietor.

40. Transfer and transmission of land of which there is a registered proprietor. Unregistered interests, &c., equitible only.-Land of which there shall be a registered proprietor may be conveyed, settled, devised, charged, and dealt with, and shall devolve, descend, and be transmissible, and subject in like manner as if this Act had not passed; save that after the first regis. tration there shall always (except in the interval between the death of a proprietor and the entry on the register of another proprietor) be a registered proprietor, and in the registered proprietor for the time being the fee simple shall by his being entered on the register as proprietor be vested, without prejudice, nevertheless, to such (if any) of the other legal estates hereinafter mentioned as may for the time being be subsisting; and the registered proprietor for the time being shall have such power of disposal and other powers &s herein before mentioned in reference to the person first registered as proprietor; the estates, rights, titles, and interests of all persons, others than such as are herein expressly declared to be legal, being equitable only.

Grants of Easements and Incorporeal Rights. 41. Grants of easements and incorporeal rights in registered land to be registered.-Any easement or any incorporeal right, other than an annuity in or over any registered land, may be created by the registered proprietor for the time being, for the purpose of being annexed to or used and enjoyed together with other land. On proof being made before him of the creation of any such easement or incorporeal right, the registrar shall enter a note thereof upon the register of the land over which such easement or other incorporeal right is to be exercised, and also (if the other land to which it is annexed, or wherewith it is to be used or enjoyed, is also registered) upon the register of such other land.

42. What legal estates there shall be in land of which there shall be a registered proprietor. Subject as the estate of the registered proprietor is to be subject in manner aforesaid, there shall be only the following legal estates and interests in land, or a rent, of which respectively there shall be a registered proprietor:

(1) The fee simple in a registered proprietor of

land: (2) The fee simple in a registered proprietor of a perpetual rent, and the powers and remedies for recovering the same, and such proprietor's powers of re-entry, if any, upon the land:

(3) Leases of which there shall be registered
proprietors :

(4) Tenancies which are, as aforesaid, not to be
deemed incumbrances :
(5) Easements and incorporeal rights created
under the power in that behalf herein
contained and of which notice shall have
been entered on the register:
(3) Estate of tenant in dower of which there
shall be a registered proprietor:

(7) Estate of tenant by the curtesy, of which there shall be a registered proprietor: (8) The estate or estates vested in the person or persons deriving title by descent or devise, and in whom the legal estate shall, under the provision in that behalf hereinafter contained, be vested in the interval between the death of a proprietor and the entry on the register of another proprietor:

And all other estates, rights, titles and interests, shall be equitable only. PART II.-Registration of Leasehold Estates and Estates in Dower and by the Curtesy. 43.-Leasehold estates may be registered in like manner as freehold lands; also estates in dower, after assignment and entry and by the curtesy.— Leasehold estates, that is to say, land demised for terms of years of which more than twenty-one years are, at the date of registration, still to come and unexpired, or demised for lives or for years determinable with lives, and in which two lives at least are still subsisting, and an estate in dower after assignment and actual entry, and an estate by the curtesy, may be registered in the name of a proprietor thereof, with a title absolute or limited, or as proprietor only, in a similar manner and subject to the same or similar directions and rules of proceeding, as herein provided, or as may be provided by general orders or rules, with respect to registration as to the fee simple.

44. Who to apply for registration.-The application for registration may, as regards leasehold land, be made by persons having such estates and interests therein as, having regard to the difference of tenure, are similar or correspondent to the estates and interests of the persons entitled to apply for a registration as to the fee simple, and, as regards an estate in dower, or by the curtesy, by the tenant in dower, or by the curtesy.

45. Registration not to extend to lessor's title unless investigated by registrar. As regards lease hold estates, the registration shall not extend to the title of the lessor or grantor unless the registrar has investigated and is satisfied with the same, and makes an entry upon the register to that effect; in which case, the validity of the lease shall not afterwards be impeachable, as against the registered proprietor thereof, or any one claiming under or entitled to the protection of the registered title, on the ground of any want of power in the lessor or grantor to make the same.

46. Estate of the registered proprietor of leaseholds.-Leasehold land shall be vested in and held by the registered proprietor for the remainder of the term for which the land was demised, subject to all the clauses, covenants, conditions, and agreements, as to rent and otherwise, contained in the lease under which the same is held.

47. Estate of the registered proprietor of estate in dower.-Land held by a tenant in dower shall be vested in and held by the registered proprietor as tenant thereof for his own life.

48. Estate of the registered proprietor of estate by the curtesy.-Land held by a tenant by the curtesy shall be vested in and held by the registered proprietor as tenant thereof for his own life.

49. Leaseholds and estates in dower and by the curtesy to be subject to prior estates.-In the case as well of leaseholds, as of an estate in dower, and by the curtesy, the lease and land and estate shall be subject to all prior estates, rights, interests, underleases, charges, and incumbrances mentioned on the register, and to all other rights and charges affecting the same, which, if the land had been held in fee simple and registered accordingly, would have been expressly preserved by this Act or declared by this Act not to be incumbrances.

50. Provisions as to trusts, &c., to be applicable. -The provisions of this Act as to trusts, and the powers of disposal of the registered proprietor, and legal and equitable estates, and other the provisions of this Act which can be applied to leaseholds and an estate in dower and by the curtesy respectively, shall extend and apply to leasehold estates, and an estate in dower, and by the curtesy, as nearly as the difference between registration of a proprietor in fee and of a proprietor for a term of years or for life will admit of; but the registrar may dispense with such, if any, of the proceedings as he shall think may properly be dispensed with, having regard to any previous proceedings in respect of the same land, and may cause such notices to be given to all or any persons or person entitled to the land or rent, subject to the term of years or estate for life as he may consider proper.

51. How the provision as to compulsory registration is to apply as to leaseholds.-As regards the provision hereinbefore mentioned for compulsory registration of sales after three years from the commencement of this Act, the following rules shall be applicable to leaseholds: a lease or underlease granted out of the fee simple or out of a leasehold estate by an unregistered proprietor, with or without a rent reserved, and with or without a premium, shall not be deemed a sale;

but any lease or underlease granted out of the fee simple or out of a leasehold estate by a registered proprietor, with or without a rent reserved, and with or without a premium, shall be deemed a sale; and an assignment upon a sale of any existing lease or underlease, whether granted by an unregistered or a registered proprietor, shall be deemed a sale.

52. Determination of leasehold estates to be entered on the register.-When any lease of which there shall be a registered proprietor shall have been determined by the re-entry of the lessor, or by the surrender of the lessee, or otherwise, the registrar, upon the same being proved to his satisfaction, and after notice given in the manner prescribed by this Act to the person appearing upon the register as proprietor of such lease, unless the registrar shall consider such notice unnecessary, shall enter upon the register where the proprietor of such lease is entered a note of the determination of such lease. PART. III.-Land Certificate, Securities by Mortgage, by deposit of Land Certificate, and by Charge under this Act.

53. Land certificate.-On the application of the registered proprietor for the time being of land, or a lease, the registrar shall deliver to him a certificate, in this Act called "a land certificate," in the prescribed form, and authenticated in the prescribed manner.

Every land certificate shall contain a transcript of the part of the registrar relating to such land or lease at the time of the delivery thereof. Every land certificate shall be primâ facie evidence of the several matters therein contained.

54. Receipts for certificates.-Before the delivery of any land certificate, a receipt for the same in the handwriting of the proprietor may be required to be signed by him, so as to prevent, as far as may be, personation.

55. Minority to be noted.-If a land certificate is delivered to a person known to the registrar to be a minor, or under any other disability, the registrar shall state on the certificate such dis. ability.

56. Note of delivery of certificate to be entered on register.-Upon the delivery of such certificate the registrar shall enter on the register a note of the delivery thereof.

57. Registrar, at the request of holder, to compare certificate with register.-At the request of the holder of the certificate, the registrar shall at any time compare the certificate with the register, and, if there has been no alteration, shall certify at the foot of such certificate that is contains a true copy of the entries in the register, and shall sign the same, and add the date of such signature. Any alteration or omission which can be conveniently made in a land certificate, or any addi tion thereto, so as to make the same correspond with any alteration in or addition to the register, may be made and signed by the registrar, if he shall think fit.

58. Loss of land certificate.-If any land certifi cate is lost or destroyed the registrar may, upon being satisfied of the fact of such loss or destruction, grant a new land certificate in the place of the former one, such new certificate mentioning that is is so granted.

59. Renewal of land certificate.-The registrar may, upon the delivery up to him of any land certificate grant a new certificate in the place of that delivered up.

60. Transferees who are mortgagees to be registered without mentioning their being mortgagees.When land or a lease of which respectively there shall be a ragistered proprietor, shall be transferred to a person as mortgagee or as a security, the transferee shall be registered as proprietor without mentioning on the register that the transaction is a mortgage or secutity, and such proprietor and the person becoming proprietor from, through, or under him, shall, as between himself and third persons, be deemed registered proprieter, with all the rights and powers of such proprietor; but as between himself and the mortgagor and persons deriving equitable estates or interests through or under him, such proprietor, and every person becoming proprietor from, through, under him, otherwise than as purchaser in fee simple for valuable consideration, shall be subject to account and redemption as a mortgagee or person having security would, independently of this Act, be

liable to account or to be redeemed.

61. Charge by deposit of land certificate.-The deposit by the registered proprietor of the land certificate, with a memorandum endorsed thereon at the time of such deposit, stating the date of the deposit and for what purpose the deposit is made, being stamped as a mortgage, shall, for the purpose of creating a lien on the land or leasehold estate described therein, be equivalent to a charge made under a power for that purpose hereinafter created, and shall take precedence of all statutory charges not previously noted on the certificate. And no charge or lien on any registered land or lease shall be created by any other deposit whatever, and no lien for unpaid purchase-money, in respect whereof a charge under this Act shall not

have been given, shall exist on such land in favour of any vendor or transferor of any land or lease or statutory charge.

62. Creation of charges.-The registered propritor of any land or lease may charge the same with the payment of any principal sum or sums of money (either ascertained or to be ascertained), either with or without interest, or with the balance which may be owing on a current or other account, or with any annual sum, and the registered proprietor for the time being of a charge shall, for all purposes of a title being made to the charge or to the land, lease. or charge affected thereby upon any transfer or of dealing therewith, have absolute power to dispose of or release, or otherwise act in reference to such charge, and to give receipts for the consideration (if any), and no transferee or other person deriving title to any such charge for valuable consideration, shall be bound or affected by any express or constructive notice of any trust, equity of redemption or equitable estate or interest, or any lis pendens relating thereto. The instrument of charge may or may not confer a power of sale, te be exercised after a time or in an event to be stated in the instrument.

63. Registration of charges and delivery of certi ficate thereof.-The registrar shall, upon the application of the person in whose favour the charge is made as the proprietor of such charge, or his legal personal representative, register such person

or

representative in like manner as entries in the register are to be made in other cases, and shall also enter on the register the particulars of the charge, and make a note of such charge on the register of the land or lease. The registrar shall, if required, deliver to the proprietor of the charge or his representative, a certificate of charge containing the particulars of the entry made on the registrar, and such certificate shall be prima facie evidence of the entry made on the register in respect of the matters mentioned in

such certificate.

64. Implied covenant to pay amount charged. Where a registered charge is created on any land or lease there shall be an implied (unless the instrument of charge contains words negativing such implication) a covenant on the part of the registered proprietor for the time being of such land or lease, with the proprietor of the charge to pay the money or balance or annual sum charged, and the interest, if any, payable thereon, at the appointed time and rate, or to pay the annual sum at the times and in the manner agreed upon.

65. Proprietor of charge may take possession.The registered proprietor of a charge for the pay. ment of any money or balance, or annual sum, may, for the purpose of obtaining satisfaction of any money due to him, at any time during the continuance of his charge, enter upon or into the receipts of the rents and profits of the land or lease, or of any part thereof, subject nevertheless to the rights of any persons appearing on the register to be prior incumbrancers, and to such, if any prior charge, as may exist by reason of a deposit of the land certificate, and to such liability to account as is enforced in courts of equity against an incumbrancer in possession. 66. Proprietor of charge with power of sale may sell. The registered proprietor of a charge for the payment of any money or balance, or annual sum, with or without interest, may, if he shall have a power of sale, exercise such power, and may transfer the land or lease, and give an effectual discharge for the purchase money, as if he were the registered proprietor of the land or lease sold, the sale and transfer to the purchaser being as complete and effectual as if the power was duly exercised, and as if the sale and transfer were made by the registered proprietor, neither the purchaser nor the registrar being concerned to inquire whether the time or event stated in the instrument shall have arrived or happened, or to regard or be affected by notice or knowledge to the contrary. But if the sale shall be subject to any prior incumbrances, the registration of the purchaser as proprietor shall be, and shall be shown on the register to be subject thereto, and liable to be overreached by any sale made in respect thereof, so long as they shall be existing incumbrances.

67. Remedy for principal sum if no such power. -The registered proprietor of a charge for the payment of any money or balance, if he shall not have a power of sale, shall have the same remedies for the recovery, by means of a sale by a court of competent jurisdiction, of any moneys due to him, as he would have in cases not within this Act, for obtaining payment of such money or balance.

68. Remedy for proprietor not having power of sale. The registered proprietor of a charge for the payment of an annual sum, if he shall not have a power of sale, shall have the same remedies for the recovery of any moneys due to him as he would have in cases not within this Act for obtaining payment of such moneys.

69. On sale prior incumbrances to be paid off. Upon any sale by a registered proprietor of a

charge under a power of sale, or upon any sale by
the court, prior incumbrancers shall be obliged to
accept payment by the vendor, or out of the pur-
chase moneys, of the moneys secured to them, but
only on having such notices (if any) as mortga-
gees are entitled to.

70. Production of land certificate on registration
of charges.-In case there shall have been given
by the registrar a land certificate of the land or
lease to be charged, no person shall be registered
as proprietor of a charge under this Act without
production of such certificate to the registrar,
unless such reason be assigned for its non-produc.
tion as may be approved by the registrar; and it
shall be the duty of the registrar to note upon the
certificate, when produced, notice of any such
charge.

71. Priority of registered charges.-Registered
charges on the same land or lease shall, as between
themselves, rank according to the order in which
they are entered on the register, and not according
to the order in which they are created, and they
shall be so entered in the order in which applica-
tion for registry shall be made.

72. Discharge. The registrar shall, on the
requisition of the proprietor of any charge, or on
due proof of the satisfaction thereof, enter a note
of discharge thereof on the register; and, upon
such entry being made, the land or lease shall be
deemed to be discharged therefrom.
PART IV.-Transfer,Devolution,and Transmission

of Lands, Leases, and Charges.
73. Registration of transfer of land.-Upon any
registered proprietor of any land, lease, or charge
transferring the same, or part thereof (this clause
not, however, applying to a disposition by will),
and upon any sale by a registered proprieter of a
charge under the powers herein in that behalf
contained, the registrar shall, upon application
made to him, enter as registered proprietor of
such land or lease, or the part thereof transferred,
the person or persons whom the registrar would,
under the provision in that behalf hereinbefore
contained, so enter, were the case one of compul-
sory registration upon sale as aforesaid, and as
registered proprietor of such charge, or part
thereof, the transferee thereof (such entries
respectively being similar as near as may be to
the original entries), and until such entry is made
the transferor shall be deemed to remain pro-
prietor thereof respectively. If any transfer of
land be made subject to any power of re-entry,
shifting clause, restriction or condition, notice
thereof shall be entered on the register. Before
completion of the registry the transferor shall
deliver up to the registrar the land certificate or
certificate of charge (if any) which shall have been
given by the registrar, unless some reason for its
non-production satisfactory to the registrar be
given.

sole, or it shall be lawful for any such registered proprietor to make such transfer to himself jointly with his wife.

77. Entries on register of claims to dower and curtesy and of dower assigned and curtesy.-Upon application by a person claiming to be entitled to dower or to curtesy, such application being supported by an affidavit as hereafter provided as to caveats, the registrar shall enter on the register of the fee simple a note of such claim, which entry shall be treated and considered as a caveat entered under Part V. of this Act, and upon the registrar being satisfied that such person is entitled to dower after assignment and entry or to curtesy, he shall enter her or him on the register as proprietor for her or his life in the manner prescribed in that behalf in Part II. of this Act.

78. On death of a proprietor a real representative to be registered as proprietor.-On the death of a sole registered proprietor, or the survivor of several registered proprietors in fee simple of any land, such person or persons as such proprietor or surviving proprietor shall by will have expressly appointed as his real representative or representatives of such land shall, upon the application of any person interested beneficially or otherwise, be entered on the register as registered proprietor or proprietors, and in case such proprietor or surviving proprietor shall not by will have expressly named a real representative or representatives. The court shall, upon the application of any person interested beneficially or otherwise, appoint a real representative or representatives, who shall be entered on the register as registered proprietor or proprietors, and the person or persons entered on the register in pursuance of either of these provisions shall be deemed to be, and have all the powers of disposal and other powers of a registered proprietor or proprietors under this Act; but as between himself or themselves, and the person or persons, if any, beneficially interested, subject in equity to the rights and interests of such person or persons. The proprietor or surviving proprietor, or the court may appoint different real representatives for different properties.

79. As to entries on sales by executors or administrators having statutory or other power of sale.-If, after the death of a registered proprietor and before or after any person shall have been registered as proprietor in his place, a sale of the registered land, or of any part thereof. shall have been made under a power of sale expressly or impliedly given by the will of the proprietor, or under a statutory power of sale, the registrar shall, but in the case of a person having been registered as proprietor, not unless the court shall have so directed, enter the purchaser, or such person or persons as he shall direct, upon the register as proprietor or proptietors of the land which shall have been so sold. 74. Marriage of female registered proprietor.80. Registrar may on the death of proprietor or The registrar, upon the production of a certificate a sale after the death of a proprietor require apof register or other sufficient proof of the marriage plication to be made, or may himself apply to the of a female registered proprietor of any land, or of court.-The registrar may, upon or after the death any female who, if unmarried would be entitled of a registered proprietor require that application to be entered on the register as registered pro- be made to the court for its direction as to the prietor of any land, and upon its being proved to person or persons to be entered as the proprietor his satisfaction that such land has not been or proprietors, or as to whether the registrar shall settled or agreed to be settled to her separate use, make an entry upon the register under the proshall enter on the register and also upon the land vision in that behalf as to entering upon the certificate (if any) of such female, the name and register a purchaser under a power of sale, or a description of her husband; or if such female person whom such purchaser shall, in that behalf, shall not have been entered on the register, the direct, and may postpone entering any person or names and descriptions of such husband and his persons as proprietor or proprietors pending such wife, and the husband of such female shall there-application, and the registrar may, if and when he upon be legal proprietor in right of his wife of shall think fit, himself apply to the court for its such land; and on the death of the husband or direction. wife the registry shall be altered, and such entry or entries made thereon as may be proper in reference to the husband being or not being tenant by the curtesy. The husband of any female proprietor of a lease or charge not settled or agreed to be settled to her separate use, shall upon his application be registered in her place.

75. Registration of married women entitled to their separate use.-The registrar, upon the production of a certificate of register or other sufficient proof of the marriage of a female registered proprietor of any land, lease, or charge, and upon its being proved to him that such land, lease, or charge is settled, or agreed to be settled, to her separate use, and in any case, of any land, lease or charge so settled, or agreed to be settled, becoming vested and registered in the name of a married woman, shall enter on the register and also upon the land certificate (if any) that such land, lease, or charge is so settled, with or without power of anticipation, as the case may be, and thereupon she, if not restrained from anticipation, may dispose thereof as a feme sole.

81. On death of proprietor the court may order registration of purchaser, &c., on sale.-If, after the death of any registered proprietor and before any person has been registered as proprietor in his place, a sale of the registered land, or of any part thereof, shall be made under the order of a court of competent jurisdiction, or specific performance of any contract for the sale thereof, or of any part thereof, shall be directed, the court making such order or so directing, may order the land so sold to be registered in the name of the purchaser as proprietor thereof, or in such other name or names as the court may order in that behalf, and the person or persons so registered shall hold such land free from all rights, titles, estates, and interests whatsoever from which he or they would have been entitled to hold the same free, if the same land had been duly transferred to him or them for valuable consideration by the deceased proprietor.

82. As to the devolution of the legal estate in the interval between death of proprietor and new registration. In the interval between death of a 76. Transfers by husband to wife.-The regis- registered proprietor, and the entry on the regis tered proprietor of any land, lease, or charge may ter of another proprietor or proprietors, the land transfer the same to his wife for her separate use, shall be legally vested in the person or persons in in which case such transfer shall be registered whom the same shall become and be from time to accordingly, it being stated therein and in the time vested by descent or devise from or under land certificate (if any) whether or not she is the deceased proprietor, or by title derived restrained from anticipation, and if not so re- through or under such descent or devise, the destrained she may dispose of the same as a femeceased proprietor being for the purposes of this

« EelmineJätka »