REPORTS OF CASES

ARGUED AND DETERMINED IN THE COURTS OF

QUEEN'S BENCH, COMMON PLEAS,

EXCHEQUER,

EXCHEQUER CHAMBER, AND COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL,

During the YEARS 1849, 1850 AND 1851.

Queen's Bench:

BY JOHN S. ARMSTRONG, ESQ. AND W. H. FALOON, Esq.

Common Pleas:

BY HEWITT POOLE JELLETT, Esq.

Exchequer:

BY GRAVES CATHREW, ESQ. AND J. P. HAMILTON, Esq.

Exchequer Chamber:

BY JOHN S. ARMSTRONG, Esq.

Court of Criminal Appeal:

BY JOHN S. ARMSTRONG, ESQ. AND W. H. FALOON, Esq.

VOL. I.

DUBLIN:

HODGES AND SMITH, 104 GRAFTON STREET.

1852.

During the period of these Reports.

COURT OF QUEEN'S BENCH.

Lord Chief Justice. The Right Hon. FRANCIS BLACKBURNE.
Second Justice.-The Hon. PHILIP CECIL CRAMPTON.
Third Justice. The Right Hon. LOUIS PERRIN.
Fourth Justice.-The Right Hon. RICHARD MOORE.

COURT OF COMMON PLEAS.

Lord Chief Justice. The Right Hon. JAMES HENRY MONAHAN.
Second Justice. The Hon. Robert Torrens.

Third Justice.-The Right Hon. NICHOLAS Ball.

Fourth Justice.-The Hon. JOSEPH DEVONSHER JACKSON.

COURT OF EXCHEQUER.

Lord Chief Baron.-The Right Hon. DAVID RICHARD PIGOT.
Second Baron.-The Hon. RICHARD PENNEFATHER.

Third Baron.-The Right Hon. JOHN RICHARDS.
Fourth Baron.-The Right Hon. THOMAS LEFROY.

NOTE. The changes which took place in the Judges and Law Officers during the period of these Reports were as follows:-In the Vacation after Trinity Term 1850 The Right Hon. JOHN DOHERTY, Chief Justice of the Common Pleas, died, upon which the Right Hon. JAMES HENRY MONAHAN, Her Majesty's Attorney-General, was appointed in his place, and JOHN HATCHELL, Esq., Q. C., Attorney-General, and HENRY GEORGE HUGHES, Esq., Q. C., Solicitor-General. In Trinity Term 1851 Serjeant STOCK resigned, and JONATHAN CHRISTIAN, Q. C., was appointed in his place.

,, 412, in reference "Sty. 292" dele "Lord Lyndhurst in note."

429, line 5 from bottom, for "Lords" read " Commons."

434, line 5 from bottom, for "according" read "acceding."

579, line 5 from bottom, for "proof of sufficient" read "sufficient proof."

591, line 13 from top, for "plaintiff excepted" read "defendant excepted."

NAMES OF THE CASES REPORTED.

Adams, Courtenay v...
Anderson v Fitzgerald
B

N.B.-v (versus) always follows the name of the Plaintiff.

...

...

Baker, Rhodes v
... 488
Bank of Ireland, Trustees of Evans's

Charities v
Beary, Smithwicke v ...

Beasley Tyrrell

Berkeley

Black v Howley
Blake, Frazer v
Blunden v Marsh
Bolton, M'Keon v
Brodrick, Callaghan v
Brown, Stradbrooke v
Brownings, Staunton v
Bryan, Madden v
Butler, Murray v
Byrne, Harte v
Byrne, The Queen v...

C

Newenham

...

...

...

...

...

A TABLE

OF THE

... 544 | Callanan, Doyle v
... 251 Carroll, Dodwell v
Carroll, Kelly v
Carr, Pounds v
Castle v Keane
Caulfield, Delacour v
Clanmorris v Lambert
Cleary v Fleming
Clements, Heenan v ...
Clements, Little v
Clooney, Lessee of Watson v
Coffey, Hoey v

Comyns v Dalgleish ...
Cooper, Watt v

Corbet v Matthews
Cotsman, Daly v
Courtenay v Adams ...
Cowan v Walker

... 484

... 192

... 599

... 485

... 669

... 519

... 331

... 44

196

58

... 107

... 495

... 85

... 63

... 137

... 544

68

3

Cranstons v Fitzgerald Crawford v Whearty... ... 222 Crommelin, In re ... 182 ... 232 Crommelin v Marquis of Donegal 244 ... 364 Cunningham, M'Clintock v .. 486

... 393
... 344

... 365

... 487

241

... 179
... 608

... 377

... 364