« EelmineJätka »
To these we owe true friendship, love sincere, 255
260 Whate'er the Passion, knowledge, fame, or pelf, Not one will change his neighbour with himself.
Ver. 261. Whate'er the Passion, &c.] III. The Poet having thus shown the use of the Passions in Society, and in Domestic life, comes, in the last place, (from ver. 260 to the end,) to show their use to the Individual, even in their illusions ; the imaginary happiness they present, helping to make the real miseries of life less insupportable : and this is his third general division :
OPINION gilds with varying rays
And not a Vanity is giv'n in vain.” Which must needs vastly raise our idea of God's goodness ; who hath not only provided more than a counterbalance of real happiness to human miseries, but hath even, in his infinite compassion, bestowed on those who were so foolish as not to have made this provision, an imaginary happiness ; that they may not be quite overborne with the load of human miseries. This is the Poet's great and noble thought; as strong and solid as it is new and ingenious. It teaches, that these illusions are the faults and follies of men, which they wilfully fall into ; and thereby deprive themselves of much happiness, and expose themselves to equal misery ; but that still, God (according to his universal way of working) graciously turns these faults and follies so far to the advantage of his miserable creatures, as to become, for a time, the solace and support of their distresses :
Tho' Man's a fool, yet God is wise.”
generally disposes men to think more seriously of the true value of things, and consequently of their provision for a future state, the consideration, that the grounds of those joys, loves, and friendships, are wants, frailties, and passions, proves the best expedient to wean us from the world ; a disengagement so friendly to that provision we are now making for another state. The observation is new, and would in any place be extremely beautiful, but has here an infinite grace and propriety, as it so well confirms, by an instance of great moment, the general Thesis, That God makes Ill, at every step, productive of Good.-Warburton.
Ver. 261. Whate'er the Passion, &c.] It was an objection constantly urged by the ancient Epicureans, that Man could not be the creature of bene, volent Being, as he was formed in a state so helpless and infirm. Montaigne took it, and urged it also. They never considered or perceived that this very infirmity and helplessness were the cause and cement of society ; that if men had been perfect and self-sufficient, and had stood in no need of each other's assistance, there would have been no occasion for the 265
The learn'd is happy nature to explore,
invention of the arts, and no opportunity for the exertion of the affections. The lines, therefore, in which Lucretius proposes this objection, are as unphilosophical and inconclusive, as they are highly pathetic and poetical :
" Tum porrò puer, ut sævis projectus ab undis
Navita, nudus humi jacet, infans, indigus omni
Lib. v. ver. 223. There is a passage in the Moralists, which I cannot forbear thinking Pope had in his eye, and which I must not therefore omit, as it serves to illustrate and confirm so many parts of the Essay on Man.
I shall therefore give it at length, without apology:
The young of most other kinds are instantly helpful to themselves, sensible, vigorous, know how to shun danger, and seek their good : a human infant is of all the most weak, helpless, and infirm. And wherefore should it not have been so ordered? Where is the loss in such a species ? Or what is Man the worse for that defect, amidst such large supplies ? Does not this defect engage him the more strongly to society, and force him to own that he is purposely, and not by accident, made rational and sociable ; and can no otherwise increase or subsist than in that social intercourse and community which is his natural state? Is not both conjugal affection, and natural affection to parents, duty to magistrates, love of a common city, community, or country, with the other duties and social parts of life, deduced from hence, and founded in these very wants ? What can be happier than such a deficiency, as it is the occasion of so much good? What better, than a want so abundantly made up, and answered by so many enjoyments? Now, if there are still to be found among mankind, such as even, in the midst of these wants, seem not ashamed to affect a right of independency, and deny themselves to be by nature sociable ; where would their shame have been had Nature otherwise supplied their wants ? What duty or obligation had been ever thought of? What respect or reverence of parents, magistrates, their country, or their kind ? Would not their full and self-sufficient state more strongly have determined them to throw off nature, and deny the ends and Author of their creation ?"Warton.
Ver. 270. the poet in his Muse.] The author having said, that no one could change his own profession or views for those of another, intended to carry his observation still further, and show that men were unwilling to exchange their own acquirements even for those of the same kind, confessedly larger, and infinitely more eminent, in another.
[То VOL. IV.
See some strange comfort every state attend,
Behold the child, by nature's kindly law,
To this end he wrote,
totally will shock : I question much, if Toland would be Locke.” But wanting another proper instance of this truth, he reserved the lines above for some following edition of this Essay ; which he did not live to give.-Warburton.
Ver. 271. See some strange comfort] How exquisite is this stanza of an unfinished Ode of Gray !
• Still where rosy Pleasure leads,
The strength and harmony of life."-Warton.
, whose words are : “ Nature, who so wisely has fitted the organs of our body to make us happy, seems likewise to have bestowed pride on us, on purpose, as it were, to save us the pain of knowing our own imperfections.”—Maxim 36.Warton.
Ver. 274. Hope travels through, &c.] Is this hope then no more than one of those strange comforts, those delusive pleasures, those sorts of groundless happiness, that constitute the chief enjoyment of the sot, the chemist, the poet, and the lunatic ?-Warton.
Surely a hope that quits us not when we die, must be intended by the Poet to be something more than those which the critic has above referred to. Ver. 280. And beads and pray’r-books are the toys of age :) A Satire
called, in Popery, the Opus operatum. As this is a description of the circle of human life returning into itself by a second childhood, the Poet has with great elegance concluded his description with the same image with which he set out— And life's poor play is o'er. Warburton. Ver. 280. the toys of age :] Exactly what Fontenelle says,
« Il est des hochets pour tout âge.” And Prior,
“Give us playthings for old age.” Yet it is certain that Fontenelle could not have taken this verse from
Pleas'd with this bauble still, as that before,
Meanwhile opinion gilds with varying rays
Prior, for he did not understand English, though Prior wrote it more than twenty years before Fontenelle.
De Lisle, whose translation of Virgil's Georgics is so frequently and so unjustly praised by Voltaire, has also translated, but not published, the Essay on Man. Millot has given another, published 1762.- Warton.
Ver. 286. And each vacuity of sense by pride :) An eminent Casuist, Father Francis Garasse, in his Somme Théologique, has drawn a very charitable conclusion from this principle ; which he hath well illustrated : “ Selon la Justice, (says this equitable Divine,)“ tout travail honnête doit être recompensé de louange ou de satisfaction. Quand les bons esprits font un ouvrage excellent, ils sont justement recompensés par les suffrages du public. Quand un pauvre esprit travaille beaucoup, pour faire un mauvais ouvrage, il n'est pas juste ni raisonable, qu'il attende des loüanges publiques ; car elles ne lui sont pas dues. Mais afin que ses travaux ne demeurent pas sans recompense, Dieu lui donne une satisfaction personelle, que personne ne lui peut envier sans une injustice plus que barbare ; tout ainsi que Dieu, qui est juste, donne de la satisfaction aux grenoüilles de leur chant. Autrement la blâme public, joint à leur mécontentement, seroit suffisant pour les réduire au désespoir."—Warburton.
The good father has charitably omitted to take into account the annoyance produced by the croaking of the frogs, as well as the irritation produced by the works of bad authors ; to each of whom the hearers and the readers might retort the ancient saying, “ It may be sport to you, but it is death to us."