is judicial authority so ancient as 1820 [Goodman v. Sayers, Jacob & Walker's Cases in Chancery, vol. 2] for saying "that the very definition of a good award is that it gives dissatisfaction to both parties."

In the following pages I have endeavoured to lay before the Profession the decisions in England, New South Wales and Victoria, and I hope while this book may prove useful that the Arbitration Act will be generally availed of in suitable cases.

CHAMBERS,

12 Wentworth Court,

May, 1893.

Sydney.

JAMES MORIARTY.

ALPHABETICAL LIST OF CASES CITED.

A.

Arbuckle v. Price, 4 Dowl. 174

Armstrong and Culley, In re, 4 V.L.R. (L) 178
Alexander v. Campbell, 41 L.J. (Ch.) 478

B.

Bailey v. Harb, 9 V.L.R. (L.) 322
Banks v. Banks, 1 Gale 46

Baker v. Townsend, 1 Moore 120

Bagaley v. Borthwick, 10 C.B.N.S. 64

Batty, In re, 1 E. & B. 787

Beddow v. Beddow, 5 H.L.C. 89, 9 Ch. D. 89

Beck v. Jackson, 1 C.B.N.S. 695

Birmingham and Staffordshire Gas Co. v. Ratcliffe, L.R. 6
Ex. 224, 40 L.J. Ex. 136

Blennerhassett v. Day, 2 Ball & Beatty 116

Blanchard v. Sun Fire Office, 6 Times Law R. 365

Bowker v. Evans, 15 Q.B. D. 565

Bradley v. Phelps, 6 Ex. 97

Brooker v. McPherson (Cudmore v. Same), 8 V.L.R. (L.) 154
Bottomley v. Amber, 38 LT. N.S. 545

Booth v. Davis, 3 A. & E. 200

Brumsden v. Stains Local Board, 1 C. & E. 272
Bury v. Dunn, 1 D. & L. 141

C.

Campbell v. Vickery, 6 N.S. W.R. 209

Caerleon Tin Plate Company v. Hughes and Another, 65 L.T. 115, 7 Times Law R.

Carlisle, In re, Clegg v. Clegg, L.R. 44, Ch. D. 200

Chappell v. North, 2 Q.B.D. 232

Christie v. Noble, 14 L.R. Ch. D. 203

Clout v. Metropolitan Railway Co., 46 L.T. 141
Curzey v. Aitcheson, 2 B. & C.K. B.R. 170

Cook v. Catchpole, 34 L.J. Ch. 60

Coxhead v. Mullis, 3 C.P.D. 439

Collins v. Locke, L.R. 4 App. Cases 674

Crampton and Holt v. Ridley & Co., L.R. 20 Q.B.D. 48
Compagnie du Senegal v. Woods & Co., 53 L.J. N.S. (Ch.) 166
Crossley v. Clay, 5 C.B. 581

D.

Dawson ». Fitzgerald, L.R. 1 Q.B.D.
Davis v. Starr, L.R. 41 Ch. D. 242

Deane v. Nicol and Another, 6 N.S.W. L.R. 145
Deutsche Springsteffe Gesellshaft v. Briscoe, L.R. 20 Q.B.D.

177

Dobson v. Groves, 6 Q.B. 637

Doe d. Mayo v. Carmell, 22 L.J. Q.B.

E.

Earl v. Stacker, 2 Vern 251

East and West Indian Dock Co., Appellants; Kirk and Randell, Respondents, L.R. 12 Appeal Cases 738 Ebbett's Case, 5 L.R. Ch. 202

Ebsworth v. Hickey, 1 S.C.R. 334
Edwards v. Davies, 23 L.J. Q.B.

Elliott v. South Devon Railway Co., 2 De Gex & S. 17

F.

Farrell v. Eastern Counties Railway Co., 2 Ex. 344
Fallowes v. Taylor, 7 Term R. 475

Fearn and Flynn, L.R. 5 C.P. 34

G.

Gaffney v. Killen, 12 Ir. C.L.R. App. 25

Gale v. Wingello Mining Co., Ltd., 11 S.C.R. 79
Gillett v. Thornton, 19 Equity 604

Gladwin v. Chillcote, 9 Dowl. 550

Goldsbrough and Co. v. McMahon, 8 N.S.W. L.R. 119
Goodson v. Brooke, 4 Camp. 163

H.

Haigh v. Haigh, 3 De G. F. & I. 157

Harvey v. Shelton, 7 Beav. 455, 13 L.J. Ch. 466

Hagger v. Baker, 14 M. & W. 9

Hart v. Duke, 32 L.J. Q.B. 55
Henery v. Henery, Batty 125
Hersh v. Irn Thurn, 4 C.B. N.S. 569
Hickie v. Q. S. I. Co., 4 S.C.R. 161

Hodgkinson v. Fernie and Another, 3 C.P. (N.S.) 201, 27
L.J. C.P. 66

Hoggins v. Gordon, 3 Q.B. 466

Hodgson v. Passenger Railway Co., L.R. 9 Q.B.D. 191

Hock v. Boor, 49 L.J. C.L. 665

Hutchinson v. Whitfield, Hayes (Ir. Ex.) 78

Hutchinson v. Easton, 13 Q.B.D. 867
Huntley, In re, 1 E. & B. 787

ALPHABETICAL LIST OF CASES CITED.

I.

Insall v. Morgan, 27 L.J. C.P. 75

J.

James v. Attwood, 7 Scott 841

James v. James and Bendall, L.R. 23 Q.B.D. 12
Johnstone v. Cheape, 5 Dow. H.L. 277

K.

Kimberley v. Dick, L.R. 13 Eq. 1

Kirk v. East and West India Dock Company, 12 L.R. H.L. 738 (1887).

L.

Law v. Garrett, 8 Ch. D. 26
Lewis, In re, 1 Q.B.D. 724

Lewis v. Rossiter, 44 L.J. Ex. 136

Little v. Newton, 2 M. & G. 351

Livingston v. Ralli, 24 L.J. (N.S.) Q.B. 269
Ludbrook v. Barrett, 46 L.J. C.P. 798

M.

Mason v. Haddon, 6 C.B.R. (N.S.) 526
Master v. Hamilton, 3 Jurist N.S. 722
Maunder, In re, 49 L.J. 535

Maunsell v. Ainsworth, 8 Dowling 869
Marsh v. Wood, 9 B. & C. 659

Malmesbury Ry. Co. v. Budd, L.R. 2 Ch. D. 113

Marshall v. Dresser, 3 Q.B. 875

Metcalfe v. Ives, 1 Atk. 63

Meeker and Brown, In re, 1 S.C.R. N.S. 59
Mitchell v. Harris, 2 Ves. Jn. 129
Milnes v. Robinson, 24 L.J. Ex. 179
McGillivray v. Bibby, 9 W.N. 51
Morell v. Dixon, 6 N.S.W. L.R. 145

McSharry v. Comr. of Railways, 11 N.S.W. L.R. 459

Morgan v. Mather, 2 Ves. Jr. 15
Moseley v. Simpson, 16 Eq. 226

Musgrave v. Stevens, W.N. (1881) 163

N.

Nickels v. Hancock, 7 De M. & G. 300

O.

Oliver v. Collins, 11 East 607

ix.

P.

Pappa v. Rose, L.R. 7 C.P., 41 L.J. C.P. 187
Parker v. Burroughs, Colle's Parl. Cas. 257
Palliser v. Gurney, 1 W.N. 152

Percival and Others, In re, 3 Times L.R. 150
Peterson v. Ayre, 27 L.J. Ex. 145

Piercy v. Young, L.R. 14 Ch. D. 200
Phipps v. Ingram, 3 Dowl. 669

Pickering v. Cape Town Railway Co., L.R. 1 Eq. 84
Plews, In re, 6 Q.B. 458

Plews v. Baker, 16 Equity 564

Poole v. Dixon and Others, 6 N.S.W. L.R. 145
Port Jackson Steamship Co. v. Newcastle Steamship Co.,

1 W.N. 62

R.

R. v. Veemes, C.C. Reserved, 1891, 2 Q.B.D. V. 1, 360
Randell, Saunders & Co. v. Thompson, 1 Q.B.D. 748
Reynolds v. Gray, 12 Mod. 120

Rouse and Neier, In re, L.R. C.P. 212, 45 L.J. C.P. 106
Rowcliffe v. Devon and Somerset Railway
Russell v. Russell, L.R. 14 Ch. D. 471

S.

Sahl v. MacDonnell, 7 L.R. 385, 3 W.N. 115

Sacker v. Ragozine, 44 L.T. 308

Samuel v. Cooper, 2 A. & E. 752

Scoles v. East London Waterworks, 1 Hodges 91

Scott v. Van Sandan, 1 Q.B. 102

Smith & Service, and Nelson & Sons, In re, L.R. 25 Q.B.D.

Strachan v. Dougall, 7 M.P.C. 365

Straus v. Francis, L.R. Q.B. 379

Sturgis and Another v. Lord Curzon, 21 L.J. Ex. 38

Stevenson v. Watson, L.R. 4 C.P.D. 148

Suttor v. Moore, 6 N.S.W.R. 207
Swinfen v. Swinfen, 25 L.J. C.P. 29

T.

Tandy v. Tandy, 9 Dowl. 1044
Templeman and Reed, In re, 9 Dowl. 962

Thursby v. Helbutt, 3 Mod. 272

Tillenson v. Peat, 3 Atk. 529

Tharsis Sulphur and Copper Co., Ltd., v. Loftus, L. R. 8 C.P. 1

Thomas v. Atherton, L.R. 10 Ch. D. 185

Tomkins v. Cunningham, 9 V.L.R. (E.) 142
Turner v. Goulden, L.R. 9 C.P. 57