W. H. STEVENSON, M.A., LL.B. CHARLES MILNE, M.A., LL.B. AND A. R. G. M'MILLAN, M.A., ADVOCATES OF CASES DECIDED IN THE COURT OF SESSION, COURT OF JUSTICIARY, COURT OF TEINDS, RAILWAY AND PRIVY COUNCIL, AND HOUSE OF LORDS. VOLUME LVII. OCTOBER 1919-OCTOBER 1920. EDINBURGH: JOHN BAXTER & SON, PRINTERS, ELDER STREET. LORD JUSTICE-CLERK-The Right Hon. C. SCOTT-DICKSON. LORD DUNDAS. LORD SALVESEN. LORD GUTHRIE. LORD ORMIDALE. Lord Justice - Clerk-The Right Hon. C. SCOTT-DICKSON. Lords Commissioners of Justiciary THE SENATORS OF THE COLLEGE OF JUSTICE, Under the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1887 (50 and 51 Vict. cap. 35), sec. 44. Dean of Faculty - C. D. MURRAY, K.C. A. BRIGGS CONSTABLE, K.C. Valuation Appeal Court. LORD SALVESEN. LORD MACKENZIE. LORD CULLEN. LORD HUNTER. INDEX OF CASES. Cie des Forges et Acieries de la Marine et D'Homecourt v. George Gibson & Company, Limited, 260 Clark and Others, Smith's Trustees v. 196 Clyde Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Penney v., 342 Clyde Shipping Company, Limited, Glasgow City Assessor v., 554 Cockburn and Others, Allan's Executrix v., 614 Colquhoun's Curator Bonis v. Glen's Trustee and Another, 623 Coltness Iron Company, Limited, Dobbie Commissioners of Taxation v. English, Scottish, and Australian Bank, Limited, 728 Corsar v. Archibald Russell Limited, 524 Cox, M'Euen & Company, M'Master & Company v., 504 Craig v. Lamoureux, 437 Craw's Trustees v. Baird and Others, 20 Crooke v. Inland Revenue, 560 Cumbernauld, Minister of, and Others, v. Heritors of Dumbarton, 522 Curle's Trustees v. Millar and Others, 574 Dampskibsselskabet Carl of Copenhagen, Dick-Lauder v. Leather-Cully, 104 410 Donnelly, A. G. Moore & Company v., 380 Duff, Summerlee Iron Company, Limited Dunbar & Company v. Scottish County Dundee Water Commissioners, Hunter v., 558 Dunsmure's Trustees v. Dunsmure's Trustees and Another, 142 Edge, North Staffordshire Railway Company v., 447 Edinburgh Assessor, Howard & Wyndham Limited v., 246 Edinburgh, Provost and Council of, North British Railway Company v., 344 Eisen v. M'Cabe Limited, 534 Espie v. 529 English, Scottish, and Australian Bank, Limited, Commissioners of Taxation v., 728 British Basket Company, Limited, The "E 14," 445 Farrow v. Farrow, 656 Feniscliffe Products Company, Limited, Mitchell & Muil Limited v., 277 Ferguson & Forrester Limited v. Buchanan and Others, 152 Fife Coal Company, Limited, Gordon and Another v., 616 Fife, County Council of, v. Magistrates of Kirkcaldy, 496 Fraser, Gavin's Trustee v., 595 Fraser Johnston Engineering Company, Limited v. Jeffs, 214 Fraser v. Lochgelly Iron and Coal Company, Limited, 589 Fraser and Rollins, H. M. Advocate v., 494 Fyfe v. John Menzies & Company, Limited, 22 Gala-Water District Committee v. Buchan, 647 Galloway v. Earl of Minto, 297 Gillespie, Keir v., 73 Gilmartin, Glasgow City Assessor v., 224 Glasgow City Assessor v. Clyde Shipping Glasgow Assessor v. Watson, 629 Glasgow Corporation, M'Gibbon v., 476 Glen's Trustee and Another, Colquhoun's Curator Bonis v., 623 Gordon and Another v. Fife Coal Company, Limited, 816 Graham, Stirling v., 58 Greenock and Port Glasgow Tramways Company v. Greenock Corporation, 481 Greenock Port and Harbour Trustees, Glebe Sugar Refining Company v., 374 Gregson, Brown's Trustees v., 391 Grosset v. Birrell's Trustees, 187 Hansen, Gilmour v., 518 Healy, Strathern v., 240 Heriot's Trust Governors v. Matson, 203 H.M. Advocate v. Fraser and Rollins, 494 Hollis Brothers & Company, Limited and Others, The "Lizzie," Van Liewen v., 769 Holmes, M'Murrich v., 523 Howard & Wyndham Limited v. Edinburgh Assessor, 246 Hudson & Sons, Limited, L. & N. W. Railway Company v., 452 Hudson's Trustees v. M'Intosh and Others, 571 Hulbert v. Barrie and Others, 612 London and North-Western Railway Company v. J. P. Ashton & Company, 436 London and North-Western Railway Com pany v. Hudson & Sons, Limited, 452 London Port Authority v. Orsett Union, 718 Lord Advocate v. Marquess of Zetland, 26 Low, Petitioner, 295 Macaskill, Macleod v., 72 Mackie & Company, Distillers, Limited, Macqueen v., 486 Mackinnon's Trustees v. Inland Revenue, 535 Maclaine and Others, Gatty v., 334 Maclaren and Another, Stewart v., 66, 531 Macleod v. Macaskill, 72 Macmillan v. Murray and Another, 25 Macqueen v. Mackie & Company, Distillers, Limited, 486 Melville v. Renfrewshire County Council, 68 Menzies & Company, Limited, Fyfe v., 22 Merchants Marine Insurance Company, Mill and Others v. Lady Dundas, 178 Millar and Others, Curie's Trustees v., 574 Milne's Trustees v. Milne and Others, 372 Milne's Trustees, Petitioners, 112 Minto, Earl of, Galloway v., 297 Mitchell v. Scottish Iron and Steel Com- Moncreiff's Trustee, Kelly's Trustee v., 366 Moore & Company v. Donnelly, 380 Munro and M'Mullen, Petitioners, 184, Munro and Others v. Rothfield, 165, 501 Murison's Trustee v. Murison's Trustees, 293 Murphy v. Smith and Another, 131 Murray and Another, Macmillan v., New Zealand and Australian Land Com- North British Railway Company v. Magis- North British Railway Company, Rothfield North British Storage and Transit Com- pany, Limited v. Burness and Others, 155 North of Scotland and Steam Navigation O'Malley v. Strathern, 640 O'Rourke v. Darbishire and Others, 730 Pacific Steam Navigation Company v. Pathhead Church Trustees, Minuters, 82 Peebles Hotel-Hydropathic Limited, Peti- Penney v. Clyde Shipbuilding and Engineer- Prime Gilt Box Society Trustees, Peti- Redford, Amstrong, Whitworth, & Com- Reekie and Others, Smith v., 174 Renfrewshire County Council, Melville v., 68 Richmond v. Assessor for Lanarkshire, 563 Robertson, Woodielee Coal and Coke Com- Robinson & Company, Shankland & Com- Ross, Watson v., 139 Rothfield, Munro and Others v., 165, 501 Rothfield v. North British Railway Com- Russell, Archibald v. Corsar, 524 Scottish County Investment Company, Scottish Iron and Steel Company, Limited, Scottish Motor Traction Company, Limited, Scottish Union and National Insurance Company, New Zealand and Australian Land Company, Limited v., 15, 543 Shankland & Company v. Robinson & Com- Sinnertons v. Robert Addie & Sons, Limited, Smith and Another, Murphy v., 131 Smith's Trustees v. Clark and Others, 196 Stevenson & Sons v. Maule & Son, 284 Stewart v. Maclaren and Another, 66, 531 Stirling v. Graham, 58 Stoomvaart Maatschappij Sophie H. v. Storstadt" Steamship and Others, Cana- Strathern v. Robert Graham & Sons, 644 Summerlee Iron Company, Limited v. Duff, 222 Thomson, Aikman, & Company, Limited, Traill and Others v. Traill's Trustee, 363 |